The best way to choose an accountant is to start with what you need done, then check their credentials, their experience with businesses like yours and how they will work with you. Compare at least two or three written quotes on the same brief, and look at scope and service as well as price. The steps below take you through that process in order.
Work out what you actually need help with
Accountants offer very different services, so a clear brief makes every later step easier. Before you speak to anyone, write down what you want covered. Common tasks include:
- Bookkeeping: recording income and expenses, or reviewing records you keep yourself.
- Year-end accounts: for a limited company, accounts filed at Companies House within 9 months of the year end, plus the Corporation Tax return (CT600), which is due within 12 months of the end of the accounting period.
- Self Assessment: your tax return and the 31 January and 31 July payment dates, if you are a sole trader, landlord or director with other income.
- VAT: registration, returns and advice on the right scheme. Registration is compulsory when taxable turnover goes over £90,000 in a rolling 12 months. You can get a rough feel for the numbers with our VAT calculator.
- Payroll: if you employ staff, or pay yourself a salary as a director.
- Making Tax Digital for Income Tax: if you are a sole trader or landlord, quarterly updates through compatible software may already apply to you.
- Advice: for example, whether to trade as a sole trader or through a company. Our sole trader vs limited company calculator gives a starting point, but an accountant can look at your full circumstances.
Also note whether you want a one-off job or an ongoing relationship. If you are only starting out, you might need help with registering for Self Assessment (by 5 October after the tax year in which you started self-employment) and setting up simple records. If you are growing, you may want proactive advice through the year, not just a return filed after the event.
The Making Tax Digital rules depend on your qualifying income, meaning gross self-employment plus property income. From 6 April 2026 they apply above £50,000, from April 2027 above £30,000 and from April 2028 above £20,000. If you are near one of those lines, tell prospective accountants. It affects the software and the level of support you need.
Qualifications and professional body membership
“Accountant” is not a protected title in the UK, so anyone can use it. That does not make all accountants unreliable, but it does mean you should check credentials rather than assume them.
Members of bodies such as ICAEW, ACCA, ICAS, CIMA and AAT follow their body’s rules, and you can confirm membership in the body’s public directory. A few practical checks:
- Ask which professional body the person or firm belongs to, and look them up in that body’s directory yourself.
- Ask what level of membership they hold and whether that fits the work you need. The bodies differ in focus and training, so it is reasonable to ask how the person’s background relates to your situation.
- Ask whether the firm carries professional indemnity insurance.
- Ask whether the firm is supervised for anti-money laundering purposes. You will usually be asked for identity documents when you sign up, which is normal.
- Ask whether they are authorised to act for you with HMRC as your agent, rather than using your own login details.
If someone is not a member of any body, that is not an automatic disqualification, but you then have no professional body’s rules or complaints process behind them. Weigh that up carefully.
Sector experience and the size of the practice
An accountant who regularly works with businesses like yours will usually spot the relevant issues faster. A landlord, a contractor, a shop owner and a limited company director with dividends all have different tax questions. Ask how many clients they have in your situation, and what questions those clients typically bring.
Size matters too. There is no single right answer, and each type of practice has trade-offs:
| Type of practice | Often suits | Questions to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Sole practitioner | Simple affairs and a personal relationship | Who covers holidays or illness? What happens at busy times, such as late January? |
| Small local firm | Owner-managed businesses wanting a mix of services | Will you deal with the same person each time? Who actually prepares the work? |
| Larger firm | More complex or fast-growing businesses | Will a small client get proper attention? Are there extra charges for routine queries? |
Location is less important than it used to be, as much of the work is done online. Still, some people prefer to meet in person, and local knowledge can help. You can browse accountants by region if proximity matters to you.
Software, communication and how they will work with you
This is where many working relationships succeed or fail. Ask these questions before you commit:
- Software: Which accounting software do they use or recommend? Is it compatible with Making Tax Digital if that applies to you? Who pays for the subscription, you or them?
- Your role: What do you need to do each month or quarter? Do you upload receipts, or do they chase you for them?
- Contact: Who will be your main contact, and how do you reach them: phone, email or a client portal? How quickly do they usually reply?
- Deadlines: Will they remind you of key dates and tell you early what tax you will owe, so payments on account do not come as a surprise? Our UK tax calendar shows the main dates.
- Advice: Is proactive advice included, or do you pay extra every time you ask a question?
If you are a director, ask whether they will help you plan how you pay yourself between salary and dividends. Our take-home pay calculator can help you see the effect of different choices, but an accountant should be able to explain the reasoning behind their advice.
Pay attention to how the early conversations go. If someone is slow to answer a simple question before you are a client, that is unlikely to improve afterwards.
Want an accountant who knows businesses like yours?
Tell us about your business in a couple of minutes and up to three accountants in your region will send you a quote. Free, with no obligation.
Request my free quotes →Comparing quotes without choosing on price alone
Fees vary from firm to firm, so there is no standard price to benchmark against. Several things drive the cost:
- the legal structure of your business (sole trader, partnership or limited company);
- how many transactions you have and how tidy your records are;
- whether you are VAT-registered and how often you file;
- whether payroll, Making Tax Digital updates or management accounts are included;
- how much advice and contact you expect through the year;
- how much of the work is done on software and how much by hand.
Want an accountant to quote on the same brief as everyone else? Giving each firm identical information makes the quotes far easier to compare. Through our service you can request quotes from up to three accountants in your area, and each one sends you a quote.
When the quotes arrive, set them side by side and check the following:
| What to compare | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Services included | A cheaper quote may leave out VAT returns, payroll or Companies House filings that another firm includes. |
| Fixed fee or hourly rate | Fixed fees are easier to budget for. Hourly work can be fair but can also grow without warning. |
| Extras and exclusions | Look for charges for tax enquiries, late records, extra phone calls or changes mid-year. |
| Payment terms | Is the fee monthly or annual, and what is the notice period if you leave? |
| Who does the work | A named contact and clear responsibilities are worth more than a polished pitch. |
| Credentials and insurance | Verify these in the professional body’s directory, not just from the quote. |
The lowest quote is not necessarily the best value, and the highest is not necessarily the most capable. The aim is the quote that clearly covers what you need, from someone you trust to do it well and on time. A missed deadline can cost you penalties, so reliability is worth paying for.
Red flags to watch for before you commit
- Guaranteed outcomes. Nobody can promise a particular tax saving or refund before seeing your records.
- Vague or missing credentials. If they will not say which body they belong to, or you cannot find them in its directory, ask why.
- No written terms. You should receive an engagement letter or similar document setting out the services, fees and responsibilities.
- Requests for your personal HMRC login. A properly set-up agent is authorised to act for you without needing your own credentials.
- Pressure to decide quickly. A good firm will let you compare quotes.
- Aggressive tax avoidance schemes. If a plan sounds too good to be true, ask for the details in writing and check with HMRC guidance on GOV.UK before you proceed.
- Unclear answers. You should be able to get a plain-English explanation of what they will do and why. If you cannot, they may not be the right fit.
- Signing returns you have not seen. You are responsible for what is filed in your name, so you should be able to review it first.
If something feels wrong, you do not have to proceed. It is easier to walk away before signing than to untangle an unsuitable arrangement later. For the detailed rules on any tax or filing question, check GOV.UK, HMRC or Companies House, or ask a qualified accountant. You can also read more in our UK guides.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need an accountant if I am a sole trader?
Not legally. Many sole traders with simple affairs complete their own Self Assessment return. An accountant is more useful if you have several income sources, are close to a Making Tax Digital or VAT threshold, or simply want to be sure the work is done correctly and on time.
How much does an accountant cost?
It varies by firm and depends on your business structure, the number of transactions, whether you are VAT-registered, whether payroll is involved and how much advice you want. The most reliable way to find out is to ask a few firms to quote on the same brief and compare what each includes.
Can I change accountant part-way through the year?
Yes, you can change at any time, subject to the notice terms in your agreement. Tell your current accountant, give your new one permission to request a handover and make sure any outstanding fees and deadlines are clear. Try to switch well before a filing date.